When it comes to romantic movies, we often hear about the blockbuster hits and classic favorites. But what about the hidden gems? Amazon Prime Video is a treasure trove of underrated romantic films that don’t always get the spotlight they deserve. These movies are brimming with heartfelt stories, surprising twists, and unique takes on love. Whether you’re in the mood for something quirky, heartfelt, or beautifully bittersweet, these films are waiting to be discovered. Let’s dive in and uncover some lesser-known romantic gems that deserve your attention!
Underrated Romantic Movie List (Table)
Here’s a curated table of underrated romantic movies on Amazon Prime Video, complete with all the details you need to find your next favorite love story.
| Movie Title | Genre | IMDb Rating | Brief Description |
|---|---|---|---|
| What If | Romantic Comedy | 6.8 | A charming “friend zone” love story starring Daniel Radcliffe and Zoe Kazan. |
| The Beautiful Fantastic | Romantic Drama | 6.9 | A quirky romance between a reclusive gardener and her eccentric neighbor. |
| Plus One | Romantic Comedy | 6.6 | Two single friends agree to be each other’s plus ones for wedding season. |
| The Incredible Jessica James | Romantic Comedy | 6.5 | A struggling playwright finds unexpected connection after heartbreak. |
| Begin Again | Musical Romance | 7.4 | A love letter to music and new beginnings starring Keira Knightley. |
| Juliet, Naked | Romantic Comedy | 6.6 | A woman finds herself torn between her boyfriend and a faded rock star. |
| The Map of Tiny Perfect Things | Fantasy Romance | 6.8 | A time-looping love story with a unique and heartwarming twist. |
| In Your Eyes | Fantasy Romance | 7.0 | Two strangers with a mysterious telepathic bond navigate love and distance. |
| Before We Go | Romantic Drama | 6.8 | A chance encounter between two strangers changes their lives forever. |
| Like Crazy | Romantic Drama | 6.7 | A bittersweet love story about the challenges of a long-distance relationship. |
| The Lovers | Romantic Drama | 6.1 | A tale of a middle-aged couple rekindling their spark amidst an affair. |
| The Longest Week | Romantic Comedy | 5.4 | A spoiled rich man falls for his best friend’s girlfriend in this witty rom-com. |
| Breathe | Romantic Drama | 7.2 | A moving tale of love, resilience, and triumph over adversity. |
| The Only Living Boy in New York | Romantic Drama | 6.3 | A young man discovers secrets about his parents and himself. |
| Paper Towns | Romantic Drama | 6.2 | A poetic story about young love, mystery, and self-discovery. |
| How Do You Know | Romantic Comedy | 5.4 | A love triangle unfolds between a corporate guy, a baseball player, and a woman. |
| Comet | Fantasy Romance | 6.7 | A nonlinear love story with stunning visuals and deep emotional layers. |
| Celeste and Jesse Forever | Romantic Comedy | 6.6 | A separated couple navigates their friendship and unresolved feelings. |
| Tumbledown | Romantic Comedy | 6.2 | A grieving widow bonds with a writer exploring her late husband’s legacy. |
| Ode to Joy | Romantic Comedy | 6.4 | A man with a rare condition learns to embrace love despite the odds. |
| Leap Year | Romantic Comedy | 6.5 | A woman travels to Ireland to propose, but fate has other plans. |
| Safe Haven | Romantic Drama | 6.7 | A mysterious woman finds love and a new life in a small town. |
| Catch and Release | Romantic Comedy | 6.0 | A woman discovers love and friendship after a tragic loss. |
| Irreplaceable You | Romantic Drama | 6.3 | A bittersweet tale of love, loss, and living life to the fullest. |
| It’s Kind of a Funny Story | Romantic Comedy | 7.0 | A teen finds unexpected love and healing during a mental health crisis. |
| Endless | Fantasy Romance | 4.8 | A supernatural love story where death can’t keep two souls apart. |
| A Lot Like Love | Romantic Comedy | 6.6 | A decade-long story of two friends discovering their feelings for each other. |
| Everybody Loves Somebody | Romantic Comedy | 6.4 | A bilingual rom-com about juggling love, family, and career. |
| Just Like Heaven | Romantic Comedy | 6.7 | A quirky ghostly romance starring Reese Witherspoon and Mark Ruffalo. |
| Love Finds You in Sugarcreek | Romantic Drama | 6.9 | A heartfelt story of love, faith, and small-town charm. |
1. What If
- IMDb Rating: 6.8
- Starring: Daniel Radcliffe, Zoe Kazan
- Director: Michael Dowse
What happens when a hopeless romantic meets his soulmate—who’s already in a relationship? That’s the dilemma Wallace (Daniel Radcliffe) faces in What If. He strikes up a close friendship with Chantry (Zoe Kazan), who has a long-term boyfriend, but their undeniable chemistry complicates things. This witty romantic comedy explores modern relationships, the boundaries of friendship, and the age-old question: Can men and women ever just be friends? With sharp dialogue and endearing performances, What If is a refreshing take on the rom-com genre. Radcliffe and Kazan’s chemistry carries the film, making it a must-watch for those who appreciate clever humor paired with heartfelt moments.
2. The Beautiful Fantastic
- IMDb Rating: 6.9
- Starring: Jessica Brown Findlay, Tom Wilkinson
- Director: Simon Aboud
This whimsical story follows Bella (Jessica Brown Findlay), a socially awkward woman with a love for order and a dream of writing a children’s book. Her world changes when her messy but wise neighbor Alfie (Tom Wilkinson) pushes her to embrace chaos and cultivate an overgrown garden. The Beautiful Fantastic is a quirky romantic drama that mixes charm, wit, and inspiration. The film offers stunning visuals, delightful characters, and a story that warms the heart without being overly sentimental. Perfect for those who love understated romances.
3. Plus One
- IMDb Rating: 6.6
- Starring: Maya Erskine, Jack Quaid
- Director: Jeff Chan, Andrew Rhymer
In Plus One, single pals Alice (Maya Erskine) and Ben (Jack Quaid) decide to team up as each other’s dates for a summer full of weddings. What starts as a practical arrangement turns into something much deeper as the duo navigates awkward receptions, emotional speeches, and their growing feelings. The movie is a laugh-out-loud romantic comedy filled with relatable moments and unexpected sweetness. Erskine and Quaid’s chemistry shines, making Plus One a delightful pick for fans of feel-good rom-coms.
4. The Incredible Jessica James
- IMDb Rating: 6.5
- Starring: Jessica Williams, Chris O’Dowd
- Director: Jim Strouse
Jessica James (Jessica Williams) is an aspiring playwright recovering from a breakup. When she meets Boone (Chris O’Dowd), a recently divorced man, their witty banter and mutual vulnerabilities spark an unconventional romance. The Incredible Jessica James blends humor and heartfelt moments to deliver a refreshing take on love and self-discovery. Williams’ performance is the heart of this film, portraying a fierce, funny, and flawed character that you’ll root for from start to finish.
5. Begin Again
- IMDb Rating: 7.4
- Starring: Keira Knightley, Mark Ruffalo, Adam Levine
- Director: John Carney
Begin Again is a soulful tale about second chances in music and love. Gretta (Keira Knightley) is a songwriter recovering from heartbreak when she meets Dan (Mark Ruffalo), a struggling record producer. Together, they embark on a journey to create music that captures their emotions and dreams. Set in New York City, the film is a love letter to the transformative power of music. Directed by John Carney of Once fame, Begin Again pairs Knightley’s heartfelt performance with Ruffalo’s raw charisma. The soundtrack is equally captivating, making this film a gem for romantics and music lovers alike.
6. Juliet, Naked
- IMDb Rating: 6.6
- Starring: Rose Byrne, Ethan Hawke, Chris O’Dowd
- Director: Jesse Peretz
Juliet, Naked tells the quirky story of Annie (Rose Byrne), who’s stuck in a stagnant relationship with Duncan (Chris O’Dowd), an obsessive fan of a reclusive musician, Tucker Crowe (Ethan Hawke). When Annie writes a scathing review of Tucker’s music, it catches his attention, and the two form an unlikely connection. This romantic dramedy is a witty exploration of love, second chances, and the role music plays in our lives. Hawke’s understated charm and Byrne’s relatable performance make this film a delightful watch.
7. The Map of Tiny Perfect Things
- IMDb Rating: 6.8
- Starring: Kathryn Newton, Kyle Allen
- Director: Ian Samuels
In this imaginative romantic tale, two teenagers, Mark (Kyle Allen) and Margaret (Kathryn Newton), find themselves trapped in a time loop where the same day repeats endlessly. Instead of trying to escape, they decide to capture the “perfect moments” scattered throughout the day. The Map of Tiny Perfect Things is a heartwarming exploration of love, grief, and the beauty of life’s small details. Its clever script and captivating performances make it a must-watch for fans of romantic fantasy.
8. In Your Eyes
- IMDb Rating: 7.0
- Starring: Zoe Kazan, Michael Stahl-David
- Director: Brin Hill
Written by Joss Whedon, In Your Eyes follows two strangers, Rebecca (Zoe Kazan) and Dylan (Michael Stahl-David), who share an inexplicable telepathic bond. Despite living miles apart, they can see and feel each other’s experiences. This unique premise unfolds into a deeply emotional love story that transcends physical boundaries. With heartfelt performances and a touch of the supernatural, In Your Eyes is an underrated gem that leaves a lasting impression.
9. Before We Go
- IMDb Rating: 6.8
- Starring: Chris Evans, Alice Eve
- Director: Chris Evans
Before We Go is a tender story of two strangers, Nick (Chris Evans) and Brooke (Alice Eve), who meet by chance in New York City. Over the course of one night, they bond over their personal struggles and unspoken feelings. Directed by Chris Evans, the film is a subtle and introspective exploration of connection and vulnerability. The chemistry between Evans and Eve is palpable, making this a perfect film for those who appreciate quiet, character-driven romances.
10. Like Crazy
- IMDb Rating: 6.7
- Starring: Felicity Jones, Anton Yelchin
- Director: Drake Doremus
Like Crazy is an intimate portrayal of young love and its challenges. Anna (Felicity Jones), a British student, falls in love with Jacob (Anton Yelchin) while studying in the U.S. Their romance is tested when Anna overstays her visa and is forced to return to the UK. This bittersweet film captures the emotional highs and lows of a long-distance relationship with raw honesty. Jones and Yelchin deliver heartfelt performances that make the story painfully real.
11. The Lovers
- IMDb Rating: 6.1
- Starring: Debra Winger, Tracy Letts
- Director: Azazel Jacobs
The Lovers offers a refreshing take on rekindled romance. Mary (Debra Winger) and Michael (Tracy Letts) are a long-married couple on the brink of divorce, each having an affair. But a sudden rekindling of passion between them complicates their plans to separate. This film is a darkly funny and deeply insightful look at love, commitment, and the unpredictability of human emotions. Winger and Letts give nuanced performances, adding depth to this unconventional romantic story.
12. The Longest Week
- IMDb Rating: 5.4
- Starring: Jason Bateman, Olivia Wilde, Billy Crudup
- Director: Peter Glanz
The Longest Week is a stylish romantic dramedy that follows Conrad (Jason Bateman), a spoiled man who loses his fortune and moves in with his best friend Dylan (Billy Crudup). Complications arise when Conrad falls for Dylan’s girlfriend, Beatrice (Olivia Wilde). The film’s witty dialogue and charming performances make it an enjoyable watch, even if it doesn’t break new ground in the romance genre.
13. Breathe
- IMDb Rating: 7.2
- Starring: Andrew Garfield, Claire Foy
- Director: Andy Serkis
Based on an inspiring true story, Breathe follows Robin Cavendish (Andrew Garfield), who becomes paralyzed from polio shortly after marriage. With the unwavering support of his wife Diana (Claire Foy), Robin refuses to let his condition define him. Together, they revolutionize mobility for people with disabilities. This deeply moving film is a testament to the power of love and resilience, brought to life by Garfield and Foy’s phenomenal performances.
14. The Only Living Boy in New York
- IMDb Rating: 6.3
- Starring: Callum Turner, Kate Beckinsale, Pierce Brosnan
- Director: Marc Webb
Set against the backdrop of New York City, The Only Living Boy in New York follows Thomas (Callum Turner), a young man caught in a complicated love triangle involving his father’s mistress (Kate Beckinsale). Directed by Marc Webb (500 Days of Summer), the film offers a stylish and introspective look at love, betrayal, and self-discovery. The strong performances and captivating narrative make it worth a watch.
15. Paper Towns
- IMDb Rating: 6.2
- Starring: Nat Wolff, Cara Delevingne
- Director: Jake Schreier
Adapted from John Green’s novel, Paper Towns tells the story of Quentin (Nat Wolff), who has been infatuated with his enigmatic neighbor Margo (Cara Delevingne) for years. When Margo disappears after a series of adventurous pranks, Quentin and his friends embark on a road trip to uncover clues about her whereabouts. This coming-of-age romantic drama explores themes of love, friendship, and self-discovery, with a mix of humor and poignancy. Nat Wolff delivers a heartfelt performance, making this film a delightful watch for fans of quirky young romance.
16. How Do You Know
- IMDb Rating: 5.4
- Starring: Reese Witherspoon, Paul Rudd, Owen Wilson
- Director: James L. Brooks
How Do You Know is a romantic comedy about Lisa (Reese Witherspoon), a professional softball player caught in a love triangle between George (Paul Rudd), a sweet but struggling businessman, and Matty (Owen Wilson), a self-absorbed baseball player. Directed by James L. Brooks, the film combines humor with heartfelt moments as Lisa navigates the complexities of modern relationships. While it may not be a critical darling, the star-studded cast brings charm and lighthearted fun.
17. Comet
- IMDb Rating: 6.7
- Starring: Justin Long, Emmy Rossum
- Director: Sam Esmail
Comet is a visually stunning and non-linear love story that explores the relationship between Dell (Justin Long) and Kimberly (Emmy Rossum) across different timelines. Directed by Sam Esmail (Mr. Robot), the film blends romance with existential musings, offering a unique take on how love evolves. Long and Rossum’s chemistry is magnetic, and the film’s dreamy cinematography creates an atmospheric experience. Comet is perfect for viewers who enjoy unconventional romantic dramas.
18. Celeste and Jesse Forever
- IMDb Rating: 6.6
- Starring: Rashida Jones, Andy Samberg
- Director: Lee Toland Krieger
Celeste and Jesse Forever follows Celeste (Rashida Jones) and Jesse (Andy Samberg), a separated couple who remain best friends despite their divorce. As they navigate new relationships, unresolved feelings complicate their journey toward closure. Rashida Jones co-wrote this heartfelt and witty romantic dramedy, which balances humor with raw emotion. Jones and Samberg’s performances bring depth to a story about love, friendship, and moving on.
19. Tumbledown
- IMDb Rating: 6.2
- Starring: Rebecca Hall, Jason Sudeikis
- Director: Sean Mewshaw
Set in a picturesque small town, Tumbledown revolves around Hannah (Rebecca Hall), a widow struggling to write a biography about her late musician husband. When Andrew (Jason Sudeikis), a brash New York writer, offers to help, their unlikely collaboration leads to unexpected romance. This charming film blends heartfelt moments with sharp dialogue, elevated by Hall and Sudeikis’s natural chemistry.
20. Ode to Joy
- IMDb Rating: 6.4
- Starring: Martin Freeman, Morena Baccarin
- Director: Jason Winer
Ode to Joy tells the story of Charlie (Martin Freeman), a man with cataplexy, a condition that causes him to faint whenever he experiences strong emotions—like joy. Despite his best efforts to avoid falling in love, Charlie finds himself drawn to Francesca (Morena Baccarin), a vibrant woman who challenges his guarded outlook on life. This offbeat romantic comedy is a heartwarming reminder that love can thrive even in the face of life’s challenges.
21. Leap Year
- IMDb Rating: 6.5
- Starring: Amy Adams, Matthew Goode
- Director: Anand Tucker
In this charming rom-com, Anna (Amy Adams) plans to propose to her boyfriend on Leap Day, following an old Irish tradition. However, a series of travel mishaps leads her to enlist the help of Declan (Matthew Goode), a rugged innkeeper. Their road trip through Ireland is filled with humor, bickering, and undeniable chemistry. Leap Year is a delightful romantic adventure with picturesque scenery and lighthearted moments.
22. Safe Haven
- IMDb Rating: 6.7
- Starring: Julianne Hough, Josh Duhamel
- Director: Lasse Hallström
Based on Nicholas Sparks’ novel, Safe Haven follows Katie (Julianne Hough), a woman escaping her troubled past. She settles in a small town and falls for Alex (Josh Duhamel), a widower with two children. However, secrets from her past threaten their newfound happiness. Directed by Lasse Hallström, this romantic drama combines suspense and heartfelt moments, making it a compelling watch for fans of love stories with a twist.
23. Catch and Release
- IMDb Rating: 6.0
- Starring: Jennifer Garner, Timothy Olyphant
- Director: Susannah Grant
Catch and Release explores the aftermath of loss and unexpected love. After her fiancé’s sudden death, Gray (Jennifer Garner) discovers hidden secrets about his life. As she processes her grief, she forms an unlikely bond with Fritz (Timothy Olyphant), one of his friends. This romantic dramedy balances humor and emotional depth, with Garner delivering a heartfelt performance.
24. Irreplaceable You
- IMDb Rating: 6.3
- Starring: Gugu Mbatha-Raw, Michiel Huisman
- Director: Stephanie Laing
Irreplaceable You is a poignant love story about Abbie (Gugu Mbatha-Raw) and Sam (Michiel Huisman), childhood sweethearts who face a devastating diagnosis. Determined to prepare Sam for life without her, Abbie embarks on a mission to find him a new partner. This tearjerker explores love, loss, and the legacy we leave behind. The emotional performances and heartfelt narrative make it a deeply moving film.
25. It’s Kind of a Funny Story
- IMDb Rating: 7.0
- Starring: Keir Gilchrist, Emma Roberts, Zach Galifianakis
- Directors: Anna Boden, Ryan Fleck
Set in a mental health facility, It’s Kind of a Funny Story follows Craig (Keir Gilchrist), a teenager seeking help for his anxiety. During his stay, he forms meaningful connections, including a budding romance with Noelle (Emma Roberts). This heartwarming dramedy balances humor and sensitivity, offering a unique perspective on young love and personal growth.
26. Endless
- IMDb Rating: 4.8
- Starring: Alexandra Shipp, Nicholas Hamilton
- Director: Scott Speer
In Endless, Riley (Alexandra Shipp) and Chris (Nicholas Hamilton) are young lovers torn apart by a tragic accident. While Chris’s spirit lingers in the afterlife, they find a way to communicate, defying the boundaries of life and death. This supernatural romance offers a heartfelt exploration of grief, love, and letting go.
27. A Lot Like Love
- IMDb Rating: 6.6
- Starring: Ashton Kutcher, Amanda Peet
- Director: Nigel Cole
- A Lot Like Love* chronicles the evolving relationship between Oliver (Ashton Kutcher) and Emily (Amanda Peet) over several years. From casual hookups to deep friendship, their bond grows stronger as they navigate life’s ups and downs. This understated rom-com is filled with charming performances and relatable moments, making it a feel-good watch.
28. Everybody Loves Somebody
- IMDb Rating: 6.4
- Starring: Karla Souza, José María Yazpik
- Director: Catalina Aguilar Mastretta
This bilingual rom-com follows Clara (Karla Souza), a successful doctor who brings a coworker as her date to a family wedding. Things get complicated when her ex-boyfriend shows up, reigniting old feelings. Everybody Loves Somebody is a refreshing and relatable exploration of love, family, and self-discovery.
29. Just Like Heaven
- IMDb Rating: 6.7
- Starring: Reese Witherspoon, Mark Ruffalo
- Director: Mark Waters
In Just Like Heaven, David (Mark Ruffalo) moves into an apartment only to discover it’s haunted by Elizabeth (Reese Witherspoon), a spirited woman who doesn’t realize she’s in a coma. As they work together to uncover the truth, their unlikely partnership blossoms into romance. This heartwarming supernatural rom-com is a delightful mix of humor and sentimentality.
30. Love Finds You in Sugarcreek
- IMDb Rating: 6.9
- Starring: Tom Everett Scott, Sarah Lancaster
- Director: Terry Cunningham
This wholesome romance follows Joe (Tom Everett Scott), a single father on the run, who finds refuge in the Amish town of Sugarcreek. There, he meets Rachel (Sarah Lancaster), a kind-hearted woman who helps him heal. Love Finds You in Sugarcreek is a heartwarming story of faith, love, and redemption, perfect for those seeking a feel-good movie.
Conclusion
While these movies may not dominate the spotlight, they offer just as much heart and soul as their blockbuster counterparts. These underrated romantic gems on Amazon Prime Video are perfect for when you’re in the mood for something a little different—something unexpected yet utterly charming. So why not take a chance on one of these hidden treasures? You might just find your new favorite love story. Happy watching!